She married first, Charles W. Wingate, 1 March 1840, in Berwick, York County, Maine.(667) They were both living in Berwick when they got married.
Charles was born in Somersworth, Strafford County, New Hampshire.(668) Charles Wallingford(669) says that the Elizabeth Wallingford who married, on 1 March 1840, Charles Wingate, was daughter of Jonathan and Betsey (Bunker) Wallingford, but Shackford(670) says that it was the Elizabeth, daughter of Thomas and Anne (McCrillis) Wallingford who married Wingate. Shackford is more likely to be correct here. Elizabeth daughter of Jonathan would likely have lived in the area of Athens, Maine with her father, while this Elizabeth was down in the Berwick area. From the death record of Julia (Wingate) Stevens in Rochester(671) in 1892 we know that her mother Elizabeth Wallingford was born in Berwick. In addition, one of the sources of information used by Shackford was Mrs. Laura A. Wallingford, who married a grandson of Thomas and Anne (McCrillis) Wallingford.
Elizabeth Wallingford and Charles W. Wingate had the following children:
245 i. Joseph5 Wingate.(672)
246 ii. Eliza Wingate.(673)
247 iii. Owen Wingate.(674)
248 iv. Julia B. Wingate was born in Berwick, York County, Maine 20 July 1845.(675) (Calculated from age at death) Julia died of anasarca, 29 January 1892, in Rochester, Strafford County, New Hampshire.(676) She married Unknown Stevens.(677) He was alive when Julia died.