| Name | Joined Church | Event | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sally Ranger | Aug 12, 1827 | ||
| Ruth Sargent | Sep 29, 1828 | dis | see also Sergent |
| Amanda Clark | Sep 29, 1828 | dis | |
| Justus Jackson | May 31, 1828 | ||
| Clement Benjamin | Dec 28, 1828 | dis | |
| Marquis Benjamin | Dec 28, 1828 | ex | |
| Betsey Benjamin | Dec 28, 1828 | dis | |
| Rachel Benjamin | Dec 28, 1828 | ex | |
| Polly Jackson | Dec 28, 1828 | dis | |
| Diantha Jackson | Dec 28, 1828 | died | |
| Mary White | Dec 28, 1828 | ||
| Cynthia Norton | Dec 28, 1828 | ||
| Harry Vanornum | May 24, 1829 | ||
| John Clark | May 24, 1829 | dis | |
| Asa Fisk | Jun 13, 1829 | dismissed | |
| Jesse Staunton | Jun 13, 1829 | ex | |
| Asa Fisk Jr. | Jun 13, 1829 | dis | |
| Hannah Fisk | Jun 13, 1829 | ||
| Clarissa Gibbons | Jun 13, 1829 | ||
| Oliver Mathews | Jun 13, 1829 | dis | |
| Welthy Warren | Jun 13, 1829 | dis | |
| Bethis Ranger | Sep 27, 1829 | ||
| Roswell Willis | Apr 7, 1832 | ex | |
| Roxana Warren | Apr 7, 1832 | dis | |
| Philamela Gibbons | Apr 7, 1832 | dis | |
| James T. King | May 12, 1832 | ||
| Betsey King | May 12, 1832 | died | |
| Orison Vanornum | May 12, 1832 | dis | |
| George Vanornum | May 12, 1832 | ||
| Maryann Vanornum | May 12, 1832 | ||
| Polly Gibbons | May 12, 1832 | Handwritten "daug of Jacob" | |
| Henry Gibbons | May 12, 1832 | ||
| Carline Fanning | Aug 19, 1832 | ex | |
| Ozias Scott | Aug 25, 1832 | dis | by letter |
| Isaac Warren | May 28, 1831 | ||
| Lucinda Warren | May 28, 1831 | ||
| Philenda Warren | May 28, 1831 | by letter | |
| Hugh Finley | Jun 29, 1833 | by letter | |
| Attia Finley | Jun 29, 1833 | by letter | |
| Jane Gibbons | Jul ??, 1833 | dis | |
| Lovisa Phelps | Jul ??, 1833 | Lovisa Viall Phelps, wife of Elihu Phelps | |
| Dimond Barns | Oct 27, 1833 | ||
| Merriam Barns | Oct 27, 1833 | ||
| Norman Gibbons | Oct 27, 1833 | ||
| Albert Spencer | Oct 27, 1833 | ex | |
| Miner Benjamin | Oct 27, 1833 | dis | |
| Diana Benjamin | Oct 27, 1833 | dis | |
| Eliza McConnell | Oct 27, 1833 | by letter | |
| Marilla Blackmer | Oct 27, 1833 | dis | |
| Alanzo Blackmer | Oct 27, 1833 | ex | |
| Ann Maritta Mathews | Oct 27, 1833 | died |