| Name | Joined Church | Event | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|
| William Marihugh | Jul 15, 1809 | dis | |
| John Potter | Jul 15, 1809 | ||
| Abel Pratt | Jul 15, 1809 | ||
| Rachel Payne Pratt | Jul 15, 1809 | ||
| Dorothy Viall | Jul 15, 1809 | Possibly wife of Philip Viall where first church meetings were held | |
| Charlotte Potter | Jul 15, 1809 | Possibly wife of John Potter | |
| Rachel Pratt Viall | Jul 15, 1809 | Wife of Samson Viall | |
| Samson Viall | Sep 1, 1809 | dec | Died 1813 |
| John Brown | Oct 7, 1810 | ||
| Joseph K. Gibbons | Oct 7, 1810 | dec | |
| Susanna Bunnel | May 25, 1811 | Ex | |
| Lois Rice | Aug 31, 1811 | ||
| Benjamin Gibbons | May 23, 1816 | died | |
| Daniel Viall | May 23, 1816 | ||
| Abner Rice | May 23, 1816 | Ex | |
| Elizabeth R. Rice | May 23, 1816 | ||
| Silas Pratt | May 23, 1816 | Rachel's brother, became a minister | |
| Charles Weller | May 25, 1816 | ||
| Lois Weller | May 25, 1816 | ||
| Sarah Vanornum | May 25, 1816 | ||
| Charles Johnson | Jun 6, 1816 | ||
| William Pratt | Jun 6, 1816 | Rachel's brother> | |
| Samuel McKean Brown | Jun 6, 1816 | ex | |
| Alanson Viall | Jun 6, 1816 | ||
| Betsey Viall | Jun 6, 1816 | ||
| Spencer Brown | Jun 6, 1816 | dec | |
| Agnes Brown | Jun 6, 1816 | dec | |
| Nabby Watson | Jun 20, 1816 | ex | May 3, 1817 |
| John Vanornum | Jun 20, 1816 | dis | |
| Harriet Viall | Jun 20, 1816 | dis | |
| Benjamin Brown | Jul 4, 1816 | dec'd | |
| John Hale | Nov 21, 1816 | ||
| Abraham Vanornum Jr. | Nov 21, 1816 | ||
| Lucenia Hill | Dec 21, 1817 | excom | Sep 7, 1820 |
| William Brown | Jun 14, 1818 | dis | |
| Eunice Brown | Jun 14, 1818 | dis | |
| Orle Gibbons | Jun 14, 1818 | ||
| Chloe Clark | Sep 20, 1818 | ||
| Sophia Stewart | Sep 20, 1818 | ex | Dec 30, 1826 |
| Miriam Knox | Sep 20, 1818 | ex | Jan 28, 1832 |
| Sarah Gibbons | Nov 15, 1818 | died | |
| Acastus Warren | Nov 2, 1823 | ex | Apr 6, 1843 |
| John Sergent | Jun 27, 1824 | dis | see also Sargent |
| James Earl | Apr 29, 1826 | dis | |
| Betsey Earl | Apr 29, 1826 | dis | |
| Hannah D. Vanornum | May 27, 1827 | dis | |
| Emily Warren | May 27, 1827 | ex |