FACTS:
This Samuel Nuckolls has never been located in any Census
1885 Nebraska State census-No Nuckols
There is not Samuel Nuckols in any census who was born in Scotland
The passenger manifest of the ship that Andrew Carnegie came to America on from Scotland shows no person named Samuel or Nuckols.
There is no Samuel Nuckols born in Scotland who shows up in any US record.
No Nuckols family other than Ezra & Heath Nuckolls family settled in Nebraska.
No Nuckols were found in Pittsburgh Pennsylvania while the Carnegies lived there.
The Morning Herald, Lexington, Kentucky
September 13, 1903
Carnegie’s Boy Chum Caught by Swindlers
Among the Nebraska victims of Daniels & Co, the New York
“bankers” raided a few days ago by the police is Samuel Nuckolls, of Kenesaw
Nebraska, who for old friendship’s sake, is given a pension of $500 a year by
Andrew Carnegie. Nuckols’ parents brought him from Scotland when he was a little
boy. On the same boat was Andrew Carnegie, at that time also a small boy. The
two children became greatly attached to each other during the voyage and when
the parents of each discovered they were bound for Pittsburgh, they also became
friends. The boys kept up their friendship after Pittsburg was reached and
during the early years when they both were forced to work hard, frequently
divided salaries with each other when necessary. The Nuckolls’ decided to come
west to seek their fortune, locating in Nebraska. He homesteaded a quarter
section and for many years prospered. Carnegie remained in the East and in time
reached his present position. But the two men continued their friendship and
kept up a correspondence. Ten years ago the drouths came and farmers in Western
Nebraska met with such reverses that many lost their all. Among these was Mr
Nuckolls, Shortly afterwards, in writing to Carnegie, Nuckolls told of his loss.
Immediately the steel king arranged to pay his boyhood friend a pension of $500
per year during the balance of life. It is supposed that newspaper
advertizements induced Mr Nuckolls to invest with Daniels & Co, Denver News.
One of these unsolvable mysteries!!
The Kansas City Star Sept 6 1903
A Carnegie Pensioner Caught
Andrew Carnegie's sole Nebraska pensioner, Samuel Nuckols of Kenesaw was caught
in the collapse of Daniel & Company, the alleged get-rich-quick concern,
which was raided by the New York Police some days ago. Nuckols was induced to
invest by advertising matter which he received. Carnegie and Nuckols came to
America on the same boat when boys, and have continued their friendship ever
since. After living near each other in Pittsburgh for a number of years, Nuckols
came to Nebraska and took up homestead. When in 1892 the crop failed in Nebraska
and there was much suffering, Carnegie remembered his old-time friend and
settled a life pension of $500 a year on him.