CENSUS: 1. Clinton County Geneological Society cemetery records for Alger Cemetery, page 1.
ALGER Lyman, b. 12 Sept. 1800, d. 10 Nov. 1885
Dorcas, d. 14 Aug. 1838, age 40 y. wife of Lyman
Esther, b. 9 July, 1800, d. 25 Sept. 1872, age 72 y. 2 m. 16 . w. of Lyman
Martha, d. 21 May, 1841, age 26 y. 3 m. 6 d. wife of Lyman"."
DEATH: Allen's History of Clinton County, 1879
Reprinted in Wolfe's History of Clinton County, 1911
25 September 1872
On September 25, 1872, Mrs. Esther Alger, the aged wife of Lyman Alger, both early settlers in this township, was ruthlessly murdered. Mr. Alger, who accumulated a large fortune, was in the habit of loaning out his money, and frequently had large sums in his house. To obtain what was believed to be a large sum, it is conjectured that this deed was committed. Mrs. Alger was past seventy-two years of age, and her husband but a year her senior. They lived alone except a grandson, Judson Curtis. On the evening of the crime Mr. Alger had gone to a schoolhouse a short distance away, to attend a prayer meeting. Judson had gone over to his father's barn, forty rods distant, and the old lady was left alone at home. She was evidently busily engaged in some of her household duties about the door, having her sun-bonnet on. While thus engaged she was shot down and afterwards beaten to death with some blunt instrument, supposedly an ax. Judson heard the shot fired and, running to the house, found the dead body of his grandmother lying in the path, near the door, the house opened, and the trunk where the money was kept rifled. He gave the alarm at the school house, and the people hurried to the scene of the brutal murder, which had been committed almost in broad daylight. Between a thousand and fifteen hundred dollars were taken from the trunk. Although some arrests were made, and diligent efforts put forth to discover the perpetrators of the crime, it is still an unsolved mystery.
Clinton Daily Herald
28 September 1872
The Alger Tragedy - No Clue to the Murderer - Great Excitement
We are placed in possession of a few additional details in relation to the Alger tragedy. Mrs. Alger, the victim, is seventy years of age, and settled, with her husband, on the place thirty-six years ago. The old couple have become wealthy and have always kept a large sum of money in the house. Mr. Alger, on Wednesday evening at seven o'clock left his house to attend a prayer meeting at a school house, a quarter of a mile off. Young Curtis, a grand-son in his teens, whose father lives about forty rods distant, was left with his grandmother. The boy went to his home on some errand, heard the report of a pistol, turned and ran back and at the side door stumbled over the body of his grandmother not knowing what it was. In the house he found no one - only a lamp was burning. He soon found his dead relative covered in blood an lifeless, and ran to the school-house crying for help. The meeting was broken up and soon all was made evident. The top and back of the head was broken in a dozen places, the brains oozing out, and a pistol ball had entered the left breast. The drawer of the bureau in another room was examined and $1100 was missing, a good deal of it being gold. Of this, $200 had been received on Tuesday for cattle sold. The murder had been committed, evidently for money, and it must have been done by someone well acquainted with the house and the habits of the Algers. The idea is, that some one was watching an opportunity for robbery either from the inside or the outside, and that, as soon as the grandson left, being detected by the old lady in the act, she was shot - that she ran into the yard and the demon or demons, not knowing the effect of the shot, followed her an beat her on the head with a bludgeon until she was dead. There does not appear to be any trace of the murderer or murderers. Everything is enshrouded in mystery. The whole country has been scoured but nothing found. The grandson had not been absent from the old lady five minutes when the report of the pistol was heard. There were over twenty wounds in the head, any one, which would have proved fatal. Some persons believe the murderer was in the house, when the young man ran to the school for help. A great fear has fallen upon the whole country around the scene of this brutal murder. The excitement is intense and every nook and corner is being examined, though, as yet with no success.
Lyons Mirror
7 November 1874
The Curtis Trial for the Alger Murder
N. S. Curtis, the elder of the two of the name, is on trial for the murder of Mrs. Alger two years ago, before the District Court now in session. Some score or more witnesses have been summoned on each side, and the taking of testimony has been going on for several days. The prosecution is conducted by District Attorney Ellis, assisted by W. A. Cotton, Esq. Hart and Leffingwell for the defence.
Clinton Daily Herald
14 Noveber 1874
At the November term of the District Court, it will be remembered, after the acquittal of N. S. Curtis of the charge of murdering Mrs. Lyman Alger in 1872, District Attorney Ellis moved to dismiss the case against L. J. Curtis on the ground that the testimony was insufficient to convict him, and the State should not be put to the needless cost in an unnecessary prosecution of the younger Curtis. The latter, however, demanded his trial on the indictment, so that he would hereafter be unmolested on account of the ever recurring but never satisfactory Alger murder affair. The matter was laid over until this term, and came up this morning on the motion to dismiss the case. The Judge accordingly dismissed the case, taking occasion to say that the charge was a serious one; that in the event of defendant's being acquitted now, no amount of evidence that might hereafter be produced would avail anything, as defendant could never again be tried on this charge; whereas, if this case is dismissed, a new indictment could be found at any time here after if additional testimony to convict him should appear. In the meantime, with the present insufficient evidence, the State would be put to the unnecessary expense in the trial of this case. So this ends the Alger murder trials, probably forever. To the ruling of Judge Brannan in the case of L. J. Curtis, the defendant excepts, and the case will be carried to the Supreme Court to compel the trial of the defendant now, if possible. It is not probable that the Supreme Court will reverse Judge Brannan's decision.
Clinton Daily Herald
2 March 1875
At the November term of the District Court, it will be remembered, after the acquittal of N. S. Curtis of the charge of murdering Mrs. Lyman Alger in 1872, District Attorney Ellis moved to dismiss the case against L. J. Curtis on the ground that the testimony was insufficient to convict him, and the State should not be put to the needless cost in an unnecessary prosecution of the younger Curtis. The latter, however, demanded his trial on the indictment, so that he would hereafter be unmolested on account of the ever recurring but never satisfactory Alger murder affair. The matter was laid over until this term, and came up this morning on the motion to dismiss the case. The Judge accordingly dismissed the case, taking occasion to say that the charge was a serious one; that in the event of defendant's being acquitted now, no amount of evidence that might hereafter be produced would avail anything, as defendant could never again be tried on this charge; whereas, if this case is dismissed, a new indictment could be found at any time here after if additional testimony to convict him should appear. In the meantime, with the present insufficient evidence, the State would be put to the unnecessary expense in the trial of this case. So this ends the Alger murder trials, probably forever. To the ruling of Judge Brannan in the case of L. J. Curtis, the defendant excepts, and the case will be carried to the Supreme Court to compel the trial of the defendant now, if possible. It is not probable that the Supreme Court will reverse Judge Brannan's decision.