Samuel and Clara were said to be "of" Wayne County, NY
There is definitely a conflict over which daughter of Moses married Fairing Wilson and which one married Samuel Robinson. O. Turner does not say which of his aunts was which. The Warde book says Lydia married Samuel Robinson. The town records of West Stockbridge, MA, give the births of the children of Fairing Wilson and LYDIA.
I believe that I found "Clary" Robinson in the 1850 census in the village of Newark, Town of Arcadia, Wayne Co NY. She was age 67, born in New York. Living with her was Paulina Robinson age 32 and Anna Canouse age 29 with Theodore P. Canouse age 2. The child was born in Michigan. I would guess these might both be her daughters.
In 1860, Paulina Robinson, age 40, was living in the household of Benjamin F. Wright in Arcadia.
1830 Census. Arcadia, Wayne Co NY
1840 Census. Arcadia, Wayne Co NY
I found an Index of Land Transactions of the Holland Land Co. It lists Moses Allen, his sons, Peter and Nathaniel Allen and sons-in-law Roswell Turner, Samuel Robinson, and Smauel Woodworth.
Samuel and Clara were of Wayne County, NY
There was a family of Robinsons in Vermont. I thought perhaps Samuel might fit in that family. This is what I've learned about the Vermont Robinsons. This particular book was not a good source, but I have kept the data hoping to eventually discover more about the family. All the Samuels of appropriate age seem to have other wives.
Genalogical of the Families of Robinsons, Saffords, Harwoods and Clarks
Samuel Robinson, b. Bristol, England, 1668. Emigrated to Cambridge, MA and died there 1730. Children all born there.
A 4th Generation Samuel, b. Dec 1766, Bennington.
3rd generation Leonard, son of Samuel & Marcy. Married Eunice Homes of Dedham MA [apparenent list of children as 4th genaration does not include a Samuel]
3rd generation Samuel married Hannah Clark, Hardwick, MA
3rd generation Samuel married Esther Safford, Bennington. She was born Norwich CT 22 Sep 1750, dau of Joseph Safford [b. 1705, Ipswich MA]
3rd generation Samuel d. 3 May 1813, Bennington
4th generation Samuel married Sarah Harwood, Bennington, dau of Peter Harwood
3rd generation Moses Robinson married Mary Fay, b. Oct 16, 1743 in Hardwick MA, dau of Stephen Fay b. 1713, Harwick - emigrated to Bennington 1762 and died there 1782
4th generation Samuel married Semanthe Brush, b. 18 Feb 1772 in Bennington, dau of Nathaniel Brush, b. 1732, Bennington. [?]
4th generation Henry Allen, b. Mar 1790, son of Samuel Allen, married Ruth Webster. Had children born bet 1814 and 1825 in Bennington.
Clara ALLEN and Samuel ROBINSON had the following children: