1873 – 1881  Friedrich Horn              Elder
1873 – 1875  August Radke              Elder
1873 – 1879  Herman Hoeft           Trustee
1873 – 1879  Heinrich Wenzel       Trustee
1873 – 1874  Ernst Papke              Trustee
1875 – 1885  Robert J Horn           Trustee
1875 – 1885  Friedrich Bertram         Elder
1878 – 1893  Eduard Kuhlman       Trustee
1878 – 1915  Rudolph Streich, Sr.  Trustee
1879 – 1885  Ludwig Bruder           Trustee
1882 – 1885  August Schlager           Elder
1883 – 1886  Bernhard Wenzel        Trustee
1884 – 1886  Christian Reinke        Trustee
1885 – 1897  Ferdinand Tank         Trustee
1885 – 1888  Fred J. Keil                   Elder
1886 – 1887  August Kohnert         Trustee
1886 – 1897  Max C. Kuhlman           Elder
1886 – 1890  John Kaeding                Elder
1887 – 1890  Carl Horn                   Trustee
1889 – 1901  August Kohnert             Elder
1890 – 1892  August Adrian            Trustee
1892 – 1893  Eduard Kuhlman        Trustee
1893 – 1897  Ernst Papke               Trustee
1895 – 1902  Herman Dode                Elder
1896 – 1904  Herman Hoch                 Elder
1897 – 1907  Ernst Adrian                   Elder
1897 – 1907  Max C Kuhlman          Trustee
1899 – 1903  August Wenzel            Trustee
1902 – 1905  Emil Poch                       Elder
1904 – 1907  Fred Flemming               Elder
1905 – 1907  Carl Maurer                     Elder
1907 – 1915  Rudolph Streich, Sr.    Trustee
1907 – 1923  Max C. Kuhlman          Trustee
1907 – 1923  A. P. Bertram               Trustee
1907 – 1913  Ernst Adrian                    Elder
1907 – 1915  Fred Flemming                Elder
1907 – 1911  Carl Horn                         Elder
1911 -  1923  Carl Detloff                      Elder
1915 – 1918  Ernst Adrian                    Elder
1916  - 1923  George W. Grambau   Trustee
1918 – 1920  Carl Pagels                      Elder
1919 – 1921  Otto Schmekel                 Elder
1919 – 1923  August Kosloski               Elder
1920 – 1922  Louis Welti                       Elder
1822 -  ?       William Gross                   Elder