Wesley was married three times. First to Sarah "Sally" Alice Watson on May 25, 1819. There is some confusion about whether this marriage date is correct as it lists the groom as "Reuben" Clatterbuck. Nonetheless, Wesley is listed as living with "Sally" in the 1850 census. Their children, with the exception of Elizabeth are listed as living in a separate household in Rockbridge county in 1850. Sarah and Wesley had 13 children. It appears that Sally and Welsey and divorced as she is found in the home of her daughters in 1870 and 1880. Three of Wesley and Sally's daughters; Sarah, Lou Elenore and Lavinia, married into the Rea family.
Wesley then married Sarah Lenard Hodges about 1864. She used the surname "Clatterbuck" instead of Clatterbaugh. They had three children. They also appear to have divorced although Sarah's obituary calls her his "widow". Sarah was apparently left destitute, as she is found living in the Rockingham county poorhouse with her sons in 1870 and by herself in 1900 and died there on Sept 7, 1914.
Sarah Hodge's Obituary:
Sarah Clatterbuck dead (The Harrisonburg, VA Daily News Record, Sept. 8, 1914. p. 3 col. 7
Mrs. Sarah Clatterbuck aged ninety one years, died at 6 o'clock yesterday morning of the infirmities of age. She had been ill for several years, Mrs. Clatterbuck was the widow of the late Wesley Clatterbuck. She was a native of North Carolina. Surviving are two sons, G.W. Clatterbuck of Harrisonburg and Frank Clatterbuck, who is somewhere in the west and one daughter, Mrs. Bettie Dickson of Laruel Hill.
The funeral will be held at 1 o'clock this afternoon at Mabel Memorial Chapel. Services will be conducted by Dr. B.F. Wilson.
Wesley then married Eliza Whirley on October 14, 1875, in Augusta County, Virginia. After Wesley's death, she married Joseph Kice. They had no children.
The Children of Wesley Clatterbaugh and Sarah "Sally" Watson were:
William Clatterbaugh b. abt 1824
Elizabeth Ann Clatterbaugh b. 1827
James J. Clatterbaugh b. 1829 d. March 30, 1867
Lucinda Clatterbaugh b. abt 1830
Lucinda married Lewis Harvey Lane on Nov. 14, 1849 in Rockingham County, VA
They had two children: Amanda J. and Sarah E.
John Clatterbaugh b.October 12, 1830 d. October 1, 1854
Mary Jane Clatterbaugh b. abt. 1834 d. 1857
Mary Jane married Benjamin Humphreys in 1855.
They had a stillborn baby and Mary Jane died.
Benjamin then married Mary Jane's sister, Barbara.
Andrew M Clatterbaugh b. 1835
Sarah C. Clatterbaugh b.1835
Sarah married Ryland B. Rea
They had five children: John, Samuel, Sarah E., C.W. and Dolly
Lou Eleanor Clatterbaugh b. 1837
Barbara Ann Clatterbaugh b.abt. 1840
Barbara married Benjamin Humphreys, the widower of her sister, Mary Jane on June 9, 1858,
in Augusta County, Virginia.
They had nine children: Alfred Letcher, Delia F., Sarah L., James K., Hanna M., Louisiana V., Mary Allis, Elvira Virginia and Effie.
Lavina C. Clatterbaugh b. 1842
Lavinia married Andrew J. Rea on November 18, 1856 in Albermarle Co, Va.
They had four children: John Erasmus Miller, Sarah E., L.A., and Dolly E.
Samuel C. Clatterbaugh b. Sept 8, 1842 d. May 23, 1927
Charles Wingfield Clatterbaugh b. March 22, 1845 d. March 16, 1899.
The Children of Wesley Clatterbuck and Sarah Lenard Hodges were;
William Clatterbuck b. 1864
George Washington Clatterbuck b. March 2, 1866 d. May 16, 1937
Elizabeth "Bettie" Clatterbuck