Here is a picture of Charles's tombstone in Union Cemetery. This was sent to me by Brian Bodine.
From Ronny Bodine:
On 25 Sept 1855, Letters of Administration were granted to Philip Cool on the estate of David Bodine of Roaring Creek Township, Columbia County. The widow (unnamed) renounced to right to administer. Surety by Peter Bodine & George Hughes. (Columbia County Wills & Administration Records, vol. 3 [1850-1869], p. 166.)