There is a Phillip D. Bordine listed as their son in the Hollinger box (Marlatt file, Lenawee Co., MI Historical Society - 44, 3, 28. This file contains Bible records, records from family members, and misc notes.) However, that does not match the census records for this family.
There is a Martha Bordine, wife of David Bordine, who is buried in the town of Benson, Hamilton Co., NY. She may be related to this David Bordine, but that is just a guess right now. Hamilton County is up near Montgomery County in New York and Benson is only twenty miles north of the area where this David's father is from: Minaville/Patterson. Here is the info on that cemetery that I got off the Hamilton County, NY GenWeb site:
Cemetery located in Town of Benson, Hamilton County, N.Y. on State-owned land called Susan Cleveland Country.
Martha, wife of David BORDINE, d. Apr. 28, 1849, aged 25yr 4mo 17da
Note: in an old account book in my possession, David Bordine appears as David Bodine. Signed Helen Fyvie.
Truman, son of Henry Y. & Martha MANZER, d. July 30, 1822, aged 1yr 6mo
Infant, son of Henry & Martha MANZER, d. Apr. 11, 1816, aged 1 day
Charles H., son of Henry & (illegible but it might be Ann) MANZER, d. Mar. 18, 1860, aged 1yr 10mo
Read by Helen B. Fyvie, Chairman of Genealogical Research, Schenectada Chapter, DAR, Schenectady, N.Y., July 1962.
From: karenandburt [kennaw at msn.con]
Sent: Tuesday, November 16, 2004
Subject: Re: Crashed email
There were a few other Bordine/Bodines that I saw named in the records in Fonda, NY that I could not find much about, but I gave Deanna Smith their names to research. David M. Bordine was a witness on the mortgage of Isaac Bodine in 1834 (County Clerk's Office, Fonda, NY) , and a Martha Bordine, wife of a David Bordine, is buried in Benson, Hamilton County, died Apr. 28, 1849, at the age of 25 years (NYGenWeb).
Well, that's it! I'm sure all thos Bordine/Bodines are related...now to figure out how!
From Ronny Bodine:
1850 Dover Twp., Lenawee Co., MI: David BORDINE 28 NY farmer, Lorett? 23 NY, Elma J. 6 NY, David J. 4 NY
1860 Dover Twp., Lenawee Co., MI: David BORDINE 39 NY, Martha 33 NY, Elen 15 NY, David 14 NY, Mary 7 MI.
1870 Dover Twp., Lenawee Co., MI: David BORDINE 49 NY farmer, Martha L. 44 NY.
1880 Dover Twp., Lenawee Co., MI: David BORDINE 59 NY farmer, Martha L. 54 NY wife, Susanah SMITH 90 VT mother-in-law.
1900 Dover Twp., Lenawee Co., MI: Martha BORDINE Dec 1826 NY widowed
1910 Dover Twp., Lenawee Co., MI: Martha L. BORDINE 83 NY widowed, Jane BOVEL 55 NY dau widowed. Martha born 4 children/2 living. Jane bore 1 child/1 living.
From Muskegon (Mich.) Daily Chronicle of Wednesday, 27 Jan 1892.
Michigan Gleanings. David Bordine of Clayton, went to his barn to feed his stock. Not coming back to the house in due time his wife went out to look after him, and found him lying in the barn dead.
From Michigan Death Records:
Martha L. Bordine, dau. of John Smith & Susannah Fairfield, born 27 Dec 1826 in New York, died 26 June 1916 in Clayton, Dover Twp., Lenawee County, and buried in Dover Cemetery. Informant was Mrs. Jane Bover.
Obituary, Adrian (Mich.) Daily Telegram of Tuesday, 27 June 1916.
Clayton, June 27.---Mrs. Martha L. Bordine died at her home in Clayton at 8:30 o'clock yesterday morning at the age of 89 years. The deceased was one of the earliest settlers of Dover township. Funeral services will be held Wednesday at 1:30 at the Presbyterian church in Clayton. Burial will occur at South Dover.
Burials in Dover Center Cemetery, Lenawee County, Michigan.
David Bordine Died Jan. 26, 1892 ae 72 Mother Loretta Bordine Dec. 27, 1826 June 26, 1916