LDS says she is "of Lancaster, PA." It also says she was born on January 14, 1816 in Niles, Cayuga, New York (besides the date and place given above).
From Ronny Bodine:
From Ohio Federal Census Records:
1850 (13 Sept.) Richland Co.: James CUTLER 35 England Farmer, Eliza 35 NJ, Bertha 8 OH, Robert 4 OH.
1860 (27 July) Richland Co.: James CUTLER 45 England Farmer, Asenath 37 NY, Bertha 18 OH, Robert 14 OH, Mary 7 OH, Martin 5 OH.
1870 (15 Aug) Plymouth Twp., Richland Co.: James CUTLER 35 England, Mary E. 17 OH, Martin R. 19 OH.
On 21 Jan 1858 in Ripley, Huron County, Ohio, James Cutler married Asenath Hagan.
Burials in Pioneer's Rest Cemetery, Plymouth, Richland County, Ohio.
Eliza, wife of James Cutler, died Oct. 24, 1855, Aged 39y. 9m. & 10d. (Find A Grave Memorial # 41892029)
Asenath Cutler, wife of James Cutler, died June 1, 1864, aged 41y. 11m. 18days (Find A Grave Memorial # 41892042)
Children: Bertha (1841-1908), Robert Erven (1836-1945), Mary Eliza (1853-), Martin Reed (1855-1923).