LDS says he is "of Lancaster, PA." I am guessing that the John and Elizabeth Bodine found in the 1850 Census of Plymouth Twp., Richland Co., OH is this John. John is 35 and born in New York. His wife is Elizabeth. She is 33 and born in Ohio. The rest of his family seems to be in the area (Susanna Bodine, his mother, and siblings are in Cass Twp.). John is listed as a farmer. His brother, Abram, and Abram's wife, Cornelia, are in his household.
Joan Best forwarded the info below from Arlene Secrist. This has to apply to this John Bodine.
Real estate partitions , Richland Co., Oh. vol. 1-17 (1852-93), p. 39
pat. to sell 7 Nov. . 1860 Bodine, John, dec`d Josiah Brinkerhoff & W. B. Cuykandal, admrs. Widow - Elizabeth E. Bodine children: Bodine, David C., James E. , Sarah C., Orpha A., Udora L., Emeline.
From Ronny Bodine:
On 7 Nov 1860, Josiah Brinkerhoff and W. B. Cuykandal, administrators of John Bodine, decd, recorded a partition of real estate to sell therein naming as heirs of John Bodine, his widow, Elizabeth E. Bodine and children--David C., James E., Sarah C., Orpha A., Udora L. and Emeline. (Richland County, Ohio Real Estate Partitions, Vol. 1-17 (1852-1893), p. 39.)
Ohio Federal Census Records:
1850 Plymouth Twp., Richland County: John Bodine 35 NY farmer, Elizabeth 33 Ohio, David 5 Ohio, Sarah 3 NY, Abram 28 NY, Cornelia 25 MA.
1860 Plymouth Twp., Richland County: John Bodine 45 NY farmer, Elizbth 42 NY, David 15 OH, Sarah 13 OH, Edward 10 OH, Orpha 8 OH, Udora 5 OH, Emma 2 OH.
Indiana Federal Census Records:
1870 DeKalb County: Elizabeth Bodine 52 NY milliner, Edward J. 19 OH day laborer, Orpha A. 18 OH, Dara 15 OH, Emma 12, OH.
1900 Indianapolis, Marion County: Sarah E. Altenburg Jan 1847 OH widow 4 children born/4 living, John W. son Oct 1875 IN dentist, Elizabeth Bodine Nov 1817 NY mother widow 6 children born/5 living.