Here is an image of the 1860 Census:
He and his wife are buried in the Plymouth Greenlawn Cemetery in Richland County, Ohio (see Richland County, Ohio Cemeteries, p. 207). Also buried in that cemetery are Ella B. Bodine (1856-1917) and Leonard G. Bodine (1858-1929). I'm not sure if they are related or not, but I'd be surprised if one or both were thier children.
*This is hard to read, but it looks like their three children were born in Ohio.
From Ronny Bodine:
From Ohio Federal Census Records:
1850 (3 Sept) Plymouth Twp., Richland Co.: John BODINE 35 NY farmer, Elizabeth 33 OH, David 5 OH, Sarah 3 OH, Abram 28 NY farmer, Cornelia 25 MA.
1860 (25 July) Cass Twp., Richland Co.: Abraham BODINE 39 NY farmer, Cordelia 35 NY, Ada 8 OH, Francis 5 OH, Laura 3 OH, Susan 66 NJ seamstress, Laura 22 NY seamstress.
1870 (15 Sept) Cass Twp., Richland Co.: Abraham G. BODINE 48 NY farmer, Cordelia 46 NY, Ada 18 OH, Francis 15 OH, Laura 12 OH.
1880 (18 June) Cass Twp., Richland Co.: A. G. BODINE 56 NY farmer, C. 56 NY wife, A. O. 26 OH dau, L. A. 22 OH dau.
From Wisconsin Federal Census Records:
1900 (12 June) Portage, Columbia Co.: Clark W. LATIMER Feb 1859 OH married 10 years salesman-suspenders, Laurie March 1859 OH wife married 10 years 2 children born/2 living, Rachel May 1893 WI dau, Marjorie Feb 1899 WI dau, Cordelia BODINE April 1824 NY widowed mother-in-law 4 children born/3 living.
From Ohio Death Records:
Abraham G. Bodine, age 60, farmer, married, born in Cayuga Co., NY, died 11 Dec 1881 in Cass Twp., Richland Co.
Abraham and Cordelia Bodine were buried in the Plymouth Greenlawn Cemetery in Richland County, Ohio.