Elizabeth may not be a child of Abraham and Adriantje. She was not listed as one of their children in "History of the West Branch Valley" (p. 523). And her place of baptism is different from the others. This might be a mistake in Sinnott.
Also, in John Thomson and His Family (1889, p. 16), it says Judith Bodine only had one older sister. That must have been Catherine Bodine. So this Elizabeth died young, or she is not a daughter of Abraham.