Samuel was the youngest of the Bodine children and was still alive in 1805. He is not listed in the baptisms at the German Reformed Church of Alexandria. Those baptisms end about 1801. This Samuel is probably the Samuel Bodine who married a Sarah Wallace and was living in Philadelphia in 1850. That is a guess, though. I later found some Census info about a Samuel and Sarah Bodine living in N. Liberties Twp., Philadelphia. A comment suggested he was a son of Bodine and Mary Pickel. A Margaret Bodine was also listed (daughter?).
From Ronny Bodine:
Died 09 June 1855 in Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania. He married Sarah Wallace 13 March 1823 in Salem County, New Jersey; born 1800; died 19 October 1861 in Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania.
Pennsylvania Vital Records, 1700's-1800's. Vol III, Marriages by Rev. Thomas J. Kitts, Pastor, Canton Baptist Church, Salem County, New Jersey, page 127: 1823, March 13. Samuel Bodine to Sarah Wallace, both of Valley Works.
From Philadelphia City Directories:
1849: S. Bodine, gunsm., 5 Green.
1850: S. Bodine, gunsm., 15 Bledislow pl.
1851, 1852, 1853, 1854: S. Bodine, gunsm., 3 Jackson.
1855: Samuel Bodine, gunsm., 3 Jackson bel 5th.
From Pennsylvania Federal Census Records:
1850 Ward 6, Northern Liberties, Philadelphia: Saml BODINE 50 NJ gunsmith, Sarah 48 PA, Margarett I. 7 PA.
1860 Ward 17, Philadelphia: Sarah BODINE 59 DE shoe binder, Margaret 17 DE.
From Philadelphia Death Records:
Philadelphia, June 9, 1855: Samuel Bodine died this day of Phthisis Pulmonalis-57 years of age-(color) white. Residence No. 6 Pulvert St. J. K. Uhler, M.D.
19 Oct 1861: Sarah Bodine, age 61, died of apoplexy. Residence Columbia ave at Belgrade. Born Phila., buried Mechanic Cem.
Death Notice, The Public Ledger (Philadelphia, Pa.) of 12 June 1855.
On the 9th inst., after a lingering illness, which he bore with Christian resignation, SAMUEL BODINE, aged 57 years and 1 month. The relatives and friends of the family are respectfully invited to attend the funeral, from his late residence, No. 6 Culvert street, below Fourth, this (Tuesday) afternoon, at 3 o'clock, without further notice.
Death Notice, The Philadelphia Inquirer (Philadelphia, Pa.) of 22 Oct 1861.
BODINE--On the 19th inst., Mrs. Sarah Bodine, relict of the late Samuel Bodine, aged 61 years. The relatives and friends of the family are respectfully invited to attend the funeral, from the residence of her son-in-law, John McMillan, No. 1424 Columbia avenue (late Hanover street), this afternoon at 2 o'clock.